Big Speculation – Fat Fiction
More people on Earth are overweight than underweight. Yet the trajectory of human body size in science fiction and fantasy could be graphed with a line sloping sharply in the opposite direction. Where’s the fat?
Authors, we’re not doing anyone favors by dodging the facts of life. Fiction’s greatest purpose is to address reality in a way that frees readers to relate to it without suffering it directly. We certainly don’t make our writing any better by preempting the fat (or dark skin, or women, or children). If anything, we sabotage our stories by depriving our characters of experiences that matter to real people living in the real world.
Of course this problem has complex origins. Western fat bias is going global, and escapism will always have wide appeal, after all. However, I suspect part of the problem stems from a generally poor understanding of what fat is, how it works, and why it’s important.
Here’s the skinny on fat: Every cell in our body requires cholesterol to function. We need fat to live, so there’s no point demonizing it or pretending it has no place in speculative fiction. Furthermore, fat cells – collectively, adipose tissue – do so much more than store excess calories. Fat behaves like the other organs of the body; it actively participates in metabolism, yes, but it also influences our neurochemistry and immune system.
There is more to talk about than weight loss when it comes to fat. Isn’t it curious that different types of fat deposits predict different long term health outcomes? Isn’t it more interesting that one’s sense of satiety, of ‘fullness’, depends more on the brain’s ability to receive certain chemical signals from the gut than it does on how much is eaten? Isn’t it downright fantastic that, once upon a time, being fat was socially advantageous?
When I browse a bookstore, I see vast expanses of neglected frontier. Even the science fiction and fantasy sections are narrow and homogenous. If our art imitated life, I’d see two covers with ample main characters for every one featuring an athletic lead. It makes me want to write in the gaps. To fill the void in our fiction with fact. And fat.
Five minutes of speculation later, and I already have more ideas than I have time to develop:
- Aliens make first contact and assume that the widest person on Earth is our leader.
- A zombie epidemic starts with an appetite suppressant, and only the obese outlast the horde.
- Santa Claus trims up and loses his powers, and is nightmarishly replaced by Rumpelstiltskin.
- It turns out that the fatter one’s body, the greater one’s magic, but because using magic burns calories at a phenomenal rate, nearly all magic is applied to agriculture.
What’s your big speculation?



Hi Kay,
Robin Hobb’s Soldier Son trilogy has an element of your last suggestion to it, although it’s only the one race of people in that world that believe it.
Jo
Hey Jo, good to see you!
Quick question: Do any of those books focus on characters of that race? Or is it something in the background?
Hi Kay,
Sorry I took so long to reply.
There are strong parallels between the world of Soldier Son and the settlement of North America but how things actually work is quite scewed and different. The race in particular are secondary characters but pivotal to the plot. The main character is of a more Western / European race but finds himself tied up in and part of this secondary group. It never quite gets to the becomign one of the noble savages and being better than them at it. I can’t say much more without giving plot spoilers.
Wikipedia stuff here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soldier_Son_Trilogy
Ah, thanks. I’ll look into it.
I get so irritated by all the urban fantasy covers with outright scrawny women in leather pants. It’s like a ridiculous carnival ride: “You must be under 120 pounds and have a C-cup bra (at minimum) in order to save the world.”
Your last suggestion is kinda how I handle my lead novel character’s superpower. She’s a healer at 180 pounds and six feet in height. She burns massive amounts of calories as she works, so if she doesn’t have that buffer of fat, she could use up muscle instead or even die.
Yeah, those book covers are a bit of an affront. The denials that there’s anything weird about it are what get me, though. Whom do they imagine read these books?
Forgive me for not knowing already, but what is your book called?
I suspect there isn’t much fat scifi around because most writers write what turns them on, whether they admit it or not. I assume that a lot of scifi writers also figure that by the future there will by then be an effective way to stop being fat which doesn’t include removing parts of your stomach and intestines. At which point everyone can make a choice to be fat or not.
I’m a big fan of Wilson Barbers, who writes a lot of erotic fat/weight gain science fiction – see: http://www.dimensionsmagazine.com/dimtext/Barbers/ Particularly the Adipose Zone Page Briant stories, which are set in a world where people choose to be fat or thin. (Page, a PI, has decided to live with his natural, plump body without any scifi assistance. I have written Barbers screamy fanmail about Page; he is the only writer I’ve ever written fanmail too, actually.)
Also, for pimping purposes: I put together an anthology a few years ago with a fat male theme; it’s not all science fiction but a fair portion are, and they explore a lot of fat themes. It includes pro writers as well as some completely new ones. Also, it has me in it. http://www.lulu.com/product/paperback/the-fat-man-at-the-end-of-the-world/4060425?productTrackingContext=search_results/search_shelf/center/1
Anyway, that’s enough fat fiction pimpage.
I’ll look into those – thanks for the links.
Of course, there’s also the ‘fat is evil’ trope: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FatBastard
And, despite the fact we’re constantly told so, being over-weight isn’t really a huge blow to our healths: http://www.medicinenet.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=91817
I agree entirely. We need more people like us in our spec-fic and less people who reinforce unrealistic and unhealthy body-ideals on people!
It would be nice to see a balance, definitely. It’s the skinny ‘monoculture’ that’s worrisome.
In the interest of finding balance, Crossed Genres opened a new anthology to submissions: Fat Girl in a Strange Land
As much as anything else, it’s distinctly worrying that so many people assume future/fantastical societies will have exactly the same definitions of beauty, attractiveness and values as we do…
Indeed, being mildly overweight is apparently best — it gives a buffer against sudden and/or catastrophic illness.
I wrote about this from the other end (caloric restriction and its fraudulent claims to extend lifespan):
The Quantum Choice: You Can Have Either Sex or Immortality
http://www.starshipreckless.com/blog/?p=4389
There was an anthology of plus-sized s-f and fantasy released by a small press in 2000: Lee Martindale’s Such A Pretty Face, a title that unfortunately has also been used on several other books. The writers in the collection are predominately women, none too surprisingly. None of the stories take the theme to the extremes that Wilson Barbers does in his Adipost Zone tales.